Overview

Located in the heart of Madill, Oklahoma, The Perfect Pie Pizzeria brings a slice of genuine pizza craftsmanship to 607 S 1st St. This cozy pizza joint offers an inviting experience for locals and travelers alike, especially those craving a classic American pie or hearty wings in a friendly, small-town atmosphere.

The menu shines with crowd-pleasers such as the Half Supreme and Half Vegetable Pizza, which cleverly balances rich meats and fresh produce, and the Large Meat Lover’s Pizza, a robust option for those who prefer bold, savory flavors. Not far behind in popularity are their tempting chicken wings, known for their well-executed seasoning and traditional appeal. The inclusion of a calzone-like item hints at the kitchen’s versatility, though the spotlight truly stays on their artisanal pies.

Patrons have praised the thin crust option, describing it as perfectly crisp with just the right amount of sauce and simply crafted toppings. Customer service receives high marks, reflecting a team that embodies warmth and attentiveness—highlighted by quick order handling and friendly staff willing to take calls before opening hours. This approach creates a seamless pickup experience, especially appreciated by visitors needing convenient and efficient service.

While most feedback celebrates the quality and timeliness, a few have noted room for improvement in crust consistency and seasoning, underscoring that perfection is a moving target even for a place named "The Perfect Pie." Still, the overall consensus appreciates the balance of flavors and the welcoming vibe, making it a recommended stop for families, sports teams, and anyone seeking comfort food with a personal touch.

In summary, The Perfect Pie Pizzeria stands out as a dependable local hotspot with a focus on classic pizzas and wings, delivered with sincerity and skill. Whether you're from nearby Tish or just passing through Madill, this pizzeria promises a slice worth savoring.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite
Atmosphere
Casual

What Customers Say

joe carrigo
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Great thin crust pizza, simple sausage, perfect amount of sauce $12 for a med single topping, considering a godfather’s personal pizza is $6bucks… GREAT PIZZA, I called in around 10:30 before the doors even opened at 11, and he took my order, most places wouldn’t even answer the phone until their exact opening time. Again pleasantly pleased GREAT JOB
Jill Fishback
Dec 11,2025
5/5
I don’t know what’s better, their pizza or their customer service! Both are excellent!! I am from out of town and needed some pizzas to feed a team of softball girls. My order was ready in less than 20 minutes. Quick and easy pickup! The pizza and breadsticks were delicious! Friendliest service I’ve had from anywhere in a while. I’ll definitely be back next time we are in this area. Thank you!!
Barbara Ocegueda
Dec 11,2025
4/5
It was alright, definitely have had worse. It was just lacking in flavor for my taste, not enough sauce- the crust was almost hard and very slightly undercooked and not seasoned. The wings tasted amazing but some of them were not cleaned of feathers… expensive.
Cynthia Boyd
Dec 11,2025
5/5
I can’t say for the atmosphere because the hubs pick up our pizza. We are virgins to this lil PIZZA place in Madill, OK. We live in Tish and it’s definitely worth the drive! The only thing I will do differently next time, is get the thin crust. I could only look at the pictures from other patrons and assume I was looking at the thin crust! Don’t get me wrong peeps, the original crust is supurb!!! We WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK!!!
Scott Hale
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Friendly service and only about 10-15 minutes from the time I ordered until the pizza was brought out to my car. The meat lover was was really good and so was the house made ranch.
molly sr
Dec 11,2025
5/5
It was soooo good. You can definitely not go wrong with any of their pizzas. But the cheesy garlic bread sticks with jalapeños are highly recommend. So flavorful, it’s a must try.
laura schwartz
Dec 11,2025
4/5
Pizza was wonderful but calzones left a little to be desired. Should have ricotta cheese and a DIPPING sauce should have been given with it. The cheese was not totally melted plus I never had a calzone without marinara sauce. Will just order pizza in the future occasionally

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Top Picks for You

More Pizza Restaurants in Madill, Oklahoma, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!